Andrew Abramowitz, PLLC

attorney at law

Follow Us on LinkedInFollow Us on RSSFollow Us on E-mail
  • Home
  • Practice
  • Our Team
  • Fees
  • Blog
  • Contact

Startup Valuations and Plain English

September 6, 2016 By Andrew Abramowitz Leave a Comment

Start Up Valuations | Andrew Abramowitz, PLLCWriting his usual daily roundup in Bloomberg View, Matt Levine, a former corporate attorney and investment banker who is perhaps the only person in the world who writes in a laugh-out-loud manner about securities law, raises interesting points on two unrelated topics: startup valuation and plain English writing.

Unlike public companies, which typically have one class of stock and a known market price, Levine notes that VC-backed startups typically have multiple classes of preferred stock with liquidation preferences, among other rights. The existence of these rights means that you can’t figure out the valuation of preferred shares by simply assuming that all preferred shares are converted to common and dividing the total value by the number of shares. The shares receive an additional distribution on liquidation that makes them more valuable. But what makes it more complicated is that the effect of this right is dependent on the outcome of the company’s performance. If the company is sold for a fraction of its previous valuation, the liquidation preference will result in the preferred holders receiving perhaps all of the sale proceeds, with common receiving none. If the company goes public or is sold at a high valuation, the liquidation preference essentially becomes irrelevant. Additionally, as Levine notes, this isn’t just a distinction between preferred and common; each class may have a different liquidation preference and seniority. So, while you may be able to set a value on an entire private company based on usual financial measures, the way the pie is divided up among the classes upon sale or IPO is uncertain.

On Levine’s other topic, he points out that those focused on plain English disclosure get caught up with anachronistic phrases like “Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein.” He rightly notes that the real issue is that sometimes the topic being discussed is inherently complex – see, for example, my previous paragraph. It’s not just legal/financial topics that are hard to render for a mass audience; certain industries involve complex technology that are hard for lay people to understand. I have a client developing a technology that uses green plants to grow proteins to be used in vaccines and other medicines. That general concept is easy enough to understand, but when the company discloses (as it must) how its technology works and how that differs from competitive methods of producing those proteins, that’s about biochemistry, and most people don’t understand that. This isn’t an issue that will be solved by writing about it in the first person; ultimately, people investing in individual companies that involve obscure technology should be relying on the advice of people who understand it unless they’re experts themselves.

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditlinkedinmail

Related posts:

  1. The Shark Tank Approach to Startup Investing
  2. Crowdfunding Paternalism Redux
  3. Whether to Pay Profits out to Shareholders

Filed Under: Startup Matters

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search the Blog

Blog Topics:

  • Crowdfunding
  • Financing Transactions/Securities Offerings
  • General Corporate/M&A Matters
  • General/Miscellaneous
  • Interesting Reads Archive
  • Legal Practice Advice
  • SEC Disclosure Matters
  • Startup Matters
  • Uncategorized

Press Coverage

"Andrew Abramowitz, a lawyer in Manhattan who has worked with both buyers and sellers of private placements, said every investor should approach a private placement skeptically." -- Paul Sullivan (New York Times)

» Read more

"If the goal [...] is to protect people from losing all of their money in an illiquid investment, the current standard fails on that count, too. Andrew Abramowitz, a lawyer in Manhattan who has worked with both buyers and sellers of private placements, said a better standard might be to limit how much of their net worth people can invest." -- Paul Sullivan (New York Times)

» Read more

Sign up for Andrew Abramowitz, PLLC's Quarterly Newsletter

Your contact information is never shared or sold to any third-party.
* = required field

Browse the Blog

  • Crowdfunding
  • Financing Transactions/Securities Offerings
  • General Corporate/M&A Matters
  • General/Miscellaneous
  • Interesting Reads Archive
  • Legal Practice Advice
  • SEC Disclosure Matters
  • Startup Matters
  • Uncategorized

Rankings & Awards

Ranked #7 nationally issuer legal counsel for total dollars advised in a PIPE transaction. (PrivateRaise.com January 2016)

Find & Follow

Follow Andrew Abramowitz, PLLC on LinkedIn.

Contact Info & Directions

©2016 Andrew Abramowitz, PLLC. All rights reserved. | 565 Fifth Avenue, 9th Floor, New York, New York 10017 | Legal Disclaimer